Update on Heating Fuel Prices
  • CALL US:
    631-602-3124
  • Become a Customer
  • Pay
    Online
  • My
    Account
  • Heating Oil
    • Heating Oil Delivery
    • Payment Options
    • Tank Monitors
    • Oil Tanks
    • Clean Fuel Credit
    • Fuel Assistance Programs
  • Kerosene
  • Heating Equipment
    • Furnaces
    • Boilers
    • Water Heaters
    • Burners
    • Radiant Floor Heating
    • Ecobee Wi-Fi Thermostat
    • Repairs
    • Troubleshooting
    • Service Plans
  • A/C & Heat Pumps
    • Central Air
    • Mini-Split
    • Heat Pumps
    • A/C Repairs
    • A/C Troubleshooting
    • A/C Service Plans
  • Plumbing
  • Diesel
  • About
    • Service Area
    • Customer Reviews
    • Employment
    • Vacation Homes
    • Energy-Saving Tips
    • Newsletter
  • Contact
    • Get in Touch
    • Free Estimate
    • Request Service
    • Refer a Friend
    • Ask the Expert
    • Become a Customer
    • Specials
Home » Blog » When Should I Replace My Thermostat?

choosing thermostat new yorkEver wonder if a thermostat can go bad (as in “no longer working”-bad, not “turning to a life of crime”-bad)?

The answer, unfortunately, is yes.

A typical thermostat should last about a decade; after that point, it can start to work less reliably than it should – and as is the case with any heating equipment, you’ll be faced with a choice to repair or replace it.

How do you make that choice? Here are some rules of thumb:

Repair your thermostat if:

  • Your furnace/boiler or A/C won’t start – Problem wiring can disconnect your thermostat from your heating and cooling system; a heating and air conditioning professional should be able to fix this problem without replacing the unit.
  • Your air conditioner runs constantly – If your A/C won’t shut off, you either have a different type of wiring problem, or you have trouble with your compressor (the outdoor component of your central air conditioner / HVAC system). Again, a pro should be able to fix the problem without replacing the thermostat.

Replace your thermostat if:

  • A battery switch had no effect – If problems and funky display issues persist after you replace your thermostat batteries, you may need a new thermostat.
  • You’re experiencing uneven cooling in your home – While indoor temperatures will vary somewhat from room to room, the change shouldn’t be too drastic. If it is, you could be experiencing a cycling problem (that is, your system turns on and off too frequently). One common cause of cycling? A broken thermostat.
  • Your thermostat won’t respond to your settings – If your thermostat just won’t do what you’re telling it to do – even if you ask nicely – it may be time for a thermostat upgrade.

Ready To Replace Your Thermostat? Think “Smart”

If you’re ready to replace your thermostat, strongly consider upgrading to a Wi-Fi or smart thermostat like the Ecobee models we feature at Burt’s Reliable. Read about some of the great features of these incredibly sophisticated marvels here, or contact us to talk about them with an expert.

Ready to upgrade your current thermostat to a Wi-Fi or smart thermostat model? We can help. Contact the heating experts at Burt’s Reliable today to get a FREE, no-obligation estimate on a smart thermostat for your North Fork or East End, LI home!


$50: refer a friend

The Burts Blog

Our Service area

Newsletter

Join Us!
© 2026 Burt’s Reliable All rights reserved. 1515 Youngs Avenue, P.O. Box 696, Southold, NY 11971
Privacy Policy | Sitemap | Website by Warm Thoughts Communications, Inc.